Saturday was the last day of my semi-raw diet experiment. And the conclusion couldn’t have come soon enough. I had the worst night’s sleep on Saturday, my last day of raw eating. I couldn’t fall asleep for hours, I had all sorts of pinching nerve pains throughout my body as I was lying in bed trying to get comfortable; I felt very unlike my usual self and definitely felt like something was off.
Raw Diet Day 7 Menu
- 2 slices Sargento reduced fat Swiss cheese, Hellmann’s olive oil mayo
- Handful of raw cashews
- Nectarine
- Giant salad with a mix of leafy greens, carrots, celery, cucumber, Lindsay low sodium black olives, 3 TBSP grated parmesan cheese, a generous drizzle of cold pressed extra virgin olive oil, red wine vinegar, black pepper, AlsoSalt, fig infused white balsamic vinegar, and raw honey
- Cumber slices; celery sticks, and celery stuffed with raw almond butter, plus about 1/4 cup Fage Total 0% plain Greek strained yogurt with splashes of Tabasco
- Raw vegan banana split: medium banana, 3 scoops organic nectars raw vegan agave gelato, raw cacao nibs, raw slivered almonds, raw almond butter, fresh pineapple
- GoRaw raw fruit + nut pumpkin bar
This salad was humongous! And I ate every last bite of it. Sooooooo gooooooooooooooood!
After the delicious rawchos I had the day before, I found that I like just plain yogurt with Tabasco sauce for dipping in veggies. It’s yummy, try it!
Big salads like this are something I could never get tired of. YUM!
For my grand raw finale: 100% raw, vegan banana split!!
Pure, unbridled decadence…
- 1 medium banana sliced down the middle, 2 scoops organic nectars raw vegan cherry chocolate agave gelato; 1 scoop organic nectars raw vegan chocolate hazelnut agave gelato, raw cacao nibs, fresh pineapple, raw slivered almonds, and a generous drizzle of raw almond butter
This was the best banana split I have ever had in my life! Oh. my. GAWD! Heavenly!!
Thoughts On My Raw Food Experiment
While I never intended for this to be a lifestyle change, a seven day trial really isn’t enough time to gather an extremely elaborate report on eating a primarily raw food diet, especially because I kept dairy in. I can tell you though, without the dairy I wouldn’t have made it past 1 or 2 days. When you eliminate so many options from your diet all at once, and then can’t even cook or warm up the remaining ones, you have to have an extremely strong will and desire to commit to this type of lifestyle. That is something I do not and probably never will have.
It took me a couple of days, but I found ways to pacify the intense hunger I was feeling on this type of eating plan. Even though I was eating copious amounts of fruit, veggies, nuts, seeds, and other fat sources, I never achieved complete satisfaction. I often felt water-logged and full, but not necessarily satiated. As if something was still missing from my bloated belly. Most likely warmth, protein, and variety. I love all of the things I ate, but I found myself so bored and uninterested at times that I’d rather go without than eat another cold carrot or bowl of salad. My lack of interest in the food trumped my hunger nearly everyday. Don’t get me wrong, I wasn’t starving to the point of agony, I was just hungrier than usual and felt the choices available were hopeless in the sense that they didn’t adequately meet my needs. Whether that was psychological or not, I don’t know. All I’ve ever known is a primarily cooked diet for 30 years, 7 days on a primarily raw diet is obviously going to be awkward and feel incomplete. I imagine I would adjust eventually, but without dairy, meat and fish, or some cooked foods, that would be a hard and unhealthy road to travel down. I know it can be done, but I don’t believe that is the healthier option. Raw fibrous foods like fruit, seeds, nuts, and vegetables, are extremely good for you, but please keep in mind that we do not absorb nearly as many nutrients from raw food and they often leave us half-undigested, so you can run into a lot of dietary deficiencies if you do not take the important precautions and do extensive research on a balanced raw diet.
Costs
Being my high raw food experience was just a 7 day trial, I went overboard with all the raw novelties they sell at Mother Earth’s Storehouse. Most of the things I bought, like raw agave gelato and raw sweetened cacao nibs definitely aren’t necessary, but I’ll give you an idea of what the raw foods items that I ate cost:
- Bag of sweetened raw cacao nibs – $12.99
- Jar of raw almond butter – $10.99
- Raw nuts and seeds – $6.95 to $9.95 per lb
- Raw fruit + nut bars – $2-$3 each
- Jar of local raw honey – $8
- Fruits and veggies – vary
- Bottle of organic cold pressed extra virgin olive oil (50 servings) – $16.95
- Jar of extra virgin coconut oil – $12.95
I probably spent about $100 on fresh produce this week. Some of it was organic, some of it wasn’t; some of it was local, some wasn’t. I also live in NY state where groceries tend to be more expensive than other areas, plus I shop at expensive specialty stores like Mother Earth’s when I could find many of the products cheaper in other stores, but I’m a sucker for convenience and novelty. You could easily find better deals on the items I overpaid for, but in general, eating raw with novelty items is more expensive compared to diets that include cheaper staples like eggs, rice, canned veggies, canned tuna/salmon, beans, and bread. I went through so much fresh produce in one or two days, like a tub of organic lettuce and a pint of grape tomatoes. That’s $10 bucks right there and not much sustenance. I have a lot of nuts and seeds leftover, so they lasted longer than the week. But I went through 3/4 of the jar of raw almond butter and half the jar of raw honey.
But like I said, you can find better deals on the things I purchased, or make your own nut butters, etc. I haven’t done a side-by-side comparison of high-raw vs. traditional diet, so I could be wrong, but I know that fresh produce is quite expensive in general, unless you are buying from a local farmer’s market. So when it becomes the majority of your diet, it could get pretty pricey, especially for more than one person. But again, I haven’t done the comparison and factored in the novelty items that you can do without if you really wanted to. A lot will also depend on how much time you want to invest preparing your raw food, or just eating it as-is, etc.
There’s a lot of variables for sure. All in all, where I live, fresh produce is expensive, and you need a lot of it to be on a raw diet. It’s a very high volume diet that doesn’t provide as much nourishment or bang for your caloric-buck compared to cooked food. It takes 2 to 4 times as much fruit, nuts, and veggies to get the same nutrients you would get from say 1 serving of cooked veggies, a piece of salmon, and a baked potato. Costs aside, I was most bothered by the lack of variety and preparation methods. I didn’t exactly try every option available, but you’re still left with very little to keep the food alive.
Health Issues
Not everyone can comfortably subsist on a primarily raw diet due to digestive issues. One of the reasons I did this trial was to see how certain foods effected my digestion, and to see if omitting others helped at all. I didn’t experience any improvements in my digestive issues while doing this trial. In fact, my symptoms got much worse during much of it and they never fully subsided at any point during the week. This could be linked to dairy, or any other the other variables, I’m not sure as I didn’t do a strict elimination diet. That wasn’t my intention, per se. I mainly wanted to reduce my sodium to lose water weight, explore my raw foodism curiosity, and then see how certain foods did or didn’t effect me over the week.
The Scale
I’m happy to report that I lost 10 lbs this week. I imagine at least 60-70% or more of that is water weight, which is exactly what I was going for. I didn’t exercise at all through the week, and I’m sure I would have lost even more if I had, which isn’t necessarily a good thing. We went shopping yesterday, and even though I was eating cooked food and hydrating myself, by last night both of my legs were having the worst muscle spasms you can fathom. Obviously I lost too much water, potassium, sodium, magnesium, and calcium over the past week. Not good! Even though I ate foods rich in potassium and magnesium, I still depleted my stores too rapidly, especially because I am on prescription diuretics. So if I had exercised, I might be in the hospital right now because it would have made things much worse as evidenced by 2-3 hours of leisurely walking in hot degree weather yesterday.
You must keep your electrolytes balanced. I really should have known better being I’m on RX diuretics, but I didn’t feel the sting until yesterday. Luckily I got over it quickly, but I need to be more careful in the future.
Conclusion
Raw foodism is not for me! lol I already knew that, but it was fun to try, and I did enjoy everything that I ate. I do have a new appreciation for the low-calories that raw food offers, so I’m going to make a conscious effort to include a lot more raw foods and meals in my life. I would definitely eat a semi-high raw diet for a day now and then, and perhaps even every few months I would do a week-long marathon to shed some water weight or just to change things up. I like variety, so I don’t regret doing this, but I am glad that it’s over!!!
My first cooked meal was half of a grass-fed cheeseburger + 4 brewer’s fries at the Hyde Park Brewing Company and Steakhouse. I wish I had my camera with me! I ate half of the burger, and picked at Dustin’s raw salad a LOT! LOL!! The burger was “ok,” nothing special. Then, we picked up a cheese pizza and a turkey sub for dinner. I had a slice of pizza and half of a turkey sub. I was hungry.
Ironically, eating all of that crappy food I had the least tummy woes since starting the raw diet. My stomach didn’t bloat immediately after eating, or any other the other lovely symptoms I usually experience. I had minimal veggies all day, probably less than one serving combined, lol. I remember telling my stomach doctor in Atlanta the exact thing thing; that the last time I felt “normal” is a day I ate terribly. Interesting.
So now I’m back to normal and loving it. I love cooked food. <3 So looking forward to dinner!! Cannot wait.
Have you ever tried any special diets for any reason? What was it like?










Twitter
RSS
Facebook
StumbleUpon
{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }
Wow! Love reading your conclusion. I could never eat 100% raw – it is such a lifestyle change for me. But I love hearing your thoughts! Hope you enjoy your cooked dinner tonight.
I was vegetarian for four years in middle school/high school, then vegan for a year and a half in high school/college. I did actually weigh a lot less, but my eating habits were unbalanced and unhealthy! Now that I am an adventurous omnivore, I focus more on eating minimally processed, nutritious foods than eliminating any food groups from my diet.
This is really interesting. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I’m sure it would be easier if you transitioned into a vegan/high raw diet. I think any time you do a complete 180 and change your diet drastically it’s pretty tough. I’m sort of curious to give this a try just to see how it feels. I imagine it would be hard mostly because cooked vegetables taste so good!
Hope you find something to make your tummy feel better soon!
Thank you so much for this review! And it was great to see that you CAN do a raw foods diet w/o fancy blenders and dehydrators (even though you did say you have a dehydrator!). I am always trying to up the raw and fresh foods in my diet and the desserts you’ve made look stunning- the candy apple and the banana split!
I have done raw for a week max as well and loved the weight loss results. I suffered no side effects and felt great while I was doing it, but was too lazy/unmotivated/tempted by other foods to continue. I really wish I could get back to that though.
I hope you find what works for you and your tummy and keep us updated on what you do!
Thanks for sharing all of your findings, Jenn. I found all of your “experiments” incredibly insightful and interesting. I agree in I could never do a completely raw diet, but would find it interesting! In winter especially, I heat just about everything “just because,” so I wouldn’t last too long
That and – I’m a sucker for roasted veggies :O
The only diet I ever tried was Weight Watchers back in HS. I used my moms books and counted. I lost 3 pounds and was happy with that. I didn’t know much about fitness and maintaining weight. I usually starved myself because I thought that is how you lost weight. But other then that when I was in college and realized I wanted a change in life style calorie counting was my way to go. It got real obsessive for me and I realized that is not normal. I’ve finally learn to balance my food and calorie counting. Much happier now. So if I indulge one day, I don’t have a problem with it and move on!
I could never do a raw diet either. I think it good to incorporate raw food in a diet, but it is always good to have variety. I mean that raw banana split looks amazing! I’m sure it tasted great too.
Your raw eats this week have looked really tasty, but after looking at the cost, and not much of a change in the digestion etc, it may not be worth it. It looks like a really healthy lifestyle to live, but I would have to agree that it is not for me either. lol. And also, that is crazy how much weight you lost. Congrats, Thats seriously nuts!
Thanks for the conclusion. I love how detailed you got. When I first went high raw my body was experiencing the same waterlogged unsatisfied feelings. I was going extreme though, and EVERYTHING was raw. I’ve found a high raw 90/10 balance now that fits me. I loved reading about your experience, it really hit close to home. =)
Thank you for sharing with us the results of your raw week. I’m sorry it didn’t work out for you, but it sounds like it was a very eye-opening experience.
Either way, I enjoyed reading about it, and I have to agree. I prefer warm, cooked food, and my body seems to react better to it, too.
Just out of curiosity… If the raw foods you ate came out (for the most part) half undigested, does that mean half the calories or does the body absorb all the calories before it’s expelled? Not that I would ever live by that rule, but I was just wondering!
BTW, great blog! I’ve been following you for over a year now! Wish I had enough discipline to start my own! LOL
Wow Jenn! That sounded like a brutal week! I don’t think I could do it – kudos to you for hanging in there with it!
I did a Vegetarian for Lent experiment this year – 40 days of being vegetarian. It was fun at first, but by the end, I was like you and couldn’t wait for it to be over! I like eating vegetarian food and often do, but all day every day was a bit much for me!
Kudos to you for sticking with it for 7 days! I would have been eating chicken wings by day three.
Always love seeing your bottle of Tabasco on the table!
i think you learnt some valuable lessons overall. and i agree, i had similar symptoms as well and can speak to ur insomnia- same here. cooked has so many benefits and so does raw. combining the two seems like the best idea. and yea raw can get VERY pricey unless u stick to just fruits and veg which usually doesnt last too long. the packaged raw food tho is HELLA expensive!!
youve made some fabulous raw food over the past week! its all looked incredible mouth-watering (and fresh!) hehe. <3
wow thank you for sharing this experience with us! can’t believe you lost 10 pounds…maybe i need to do this?
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! I think it’s commendable that you did the experiment in the first place. I know I, personally, wouldn’t become a raw foodie because I enjoy cooked food way too much. Food is more than just “fuel” (like you were saying- it’s enjoyment)! And cooked food is good for you…as long as you don’t cook it to death
the desert looks great